It’s an obsession. The contemporary fantasy genre has been making sweet, soft, dirty love to vaguely medieval Western cultures for almost a century now. You can tell because the two have made so many degenerate babies that the bookshelves are full with them. Some of them are more degenerate than others, taking those medieval Western cultures as mere background rather than as setting. Others are clearly the product of a well-managed, passionate marriage (or other applicable union).
Joking aside, the reason for the clinging behavior of fantasy has more to do with the heritage of colonialism than it does with anything else. The last 400 years of empires, scientific racism, hierarchical anthropology, and so on have created a deep link within our conscious and subconscious minds that privileges the West. At some point in our cultural history, we started calling some “ancient cultures” by a new name: “primitive.” Thus, Rome became the pinnacle of the West, despite also being an “ancient culture,” and all those non-Western cultures, from Africa to Asia to the Americas, became “primitive.” “Primitive” ceased to mean “old, dead culture” and
came to mean “unsophisticated, lesser culture.”
Note the problematic distinction made between these terms. How can an equally ancient culture be “superior” to other ancient cultures? What makes them superior? A hard question to answer. Some would suggest that the West appeared superior because it rapidly advanced while the rest of the world seemed stuck “in the past.” There’s not enough space to deal with such a questionable argument here, except to say that there might be good reasons for why some cultures did not “progress” the same way as others.
In contemporary anthropology, however, “primitive” represents the earlier forms of Homo Sapiens sapiens. The Cro Magnon. The first cultures. Rudimentary. But the wider culture has yet to catch on to this usage. Instead, anything “not West” is “primitive” and, therefore, “other.” That stems from centuries of imperial rhetoric and Western superiority (a complex, really). Our culture is a product of being told we are special, and that everyone else strives to be like us, to take from us the modes of progress, and so on. The “primitive cultures” were simply “on their way to being advanced, Western ones.”
From that perspective, it shouldn’t be hard to imagine why the pseudo-medieval setting is the one that dominates fantasy, a generic tradition that began in the West and unfortunately remains there (with some exceptions). For all people in the West, the medieval period is the only medieval reference we can call “ours.” This despite the fact that many people in the West have links to other cultures (often intimate links). While these exceptions certainly value non-Western cultures, they are up against a wall which tells them “our history [the West’s] is most important, and so you should write analogues of it.”
We are starting to see a serious push against this history. The “other” is creeping its way into the dominant discourse of the West, supplanting its authority to remind us that culture is mostly relative. It’s a slow, drawn out process, just as imperialism and its cultural parasitism took decades to build and decades to tear down. That’s the way it goes, though. When you build an immense hegemonic system of oppression, control, and assimilation, you can’t expect tomorrow to be full of sun when we’ve only just started pulling its ropes on the horizon. At least we have an explanation for the obsession, though. And having that knowledge might be useful some day.
What do you all think? Which recent fantasy novels have you read that don’t include Western settings? I immediately think of work by N. K. Jemisin, Nalo Hopkinson, and Karen Lord. Things I haven’t read included Saladin Ahmed’s Throne of the Crescent Moon, the numerous Philippine SF/F anthologies that Charles A. Tan reminds us about, and a number of interesting works mentioned on the World SF blog (are Lavie Tidhar’s fantasy novels set elsewhere?). Let me know of some others. We could make a wicked list of fantasy set somewhere other than the West!
(Question provied by Mike Reeves-McMillan on Google+)
Like this:
Like Loading...
Related
Question: Why does fantasy default to pseudo-medieval?
Reading Time
It’s an obsession. The contemporary fantasy genre has been making sweet, soft, dirty love to vaguely medieval Western cultures for almost a century now. You can tell because the two have made so many degenerate babies that the bookshelves are full with them. Some of them are more degenerate than others, taking those medieval Western cultures as mere background rather than as setting. Others are clearly the product of a well-managed, passionate marriage (or other applicable union).
Joking aside, the reason for the clinging behavior of fantasy has more to do with the heritage of colonialism than it does with anything else. The last 400 years of empires, scientific racism, hierarchical anthropology, and so on have created a deep link within our conscious and subconscious minds that privileges the West. At some point in our cultural history, we started calling some “ancient cultures” by a new name: “primitive.” Thus, Rome became the pinnacle of the West, despite also being an “ancient culture,” and all those non-Western cultures, from Africa to Asia to the Americas, became “primitive.” “Primitive” ceased to mean “old, dead culture” and
came to mean “unsophisticated, lesser culture.”
Note the problematic distinction made between these terms. How can an equally ancient culture be “superior” to other ancient cultures? What makes them superior? A hard question to answer. Some would suggest that the West appeared superior because it rapidly advanced while the rest of the world seemed stuck “in the past.” There’s not enough space to deal with such a questionable argument here, except to say that there might be good reasons for why some cultures did not “progress” the same way as others.
In contemporary anthropology, however, “primitive” represents the earlier forms of Homo Sapiens sapiens. The Cro Magnon. The first cultures. Rudimentary. But the wider culture has yet to catch on to this usage. Instead, anything “not West” is “primitive” and, therefore, “other.” That stems from centuries of imperial rhetoric and Western superiority (a complex, really). Our culture is a product of being told we are special, and that everyone else strives to be like us, to take from us the modes of progress, and so on. The “primitive cultures” were simply “on their way to being advanced, Western ones.”
From that perspective, it shouldn’t be hard to imagine why the pseudo-medieval setting is the one that dominates fantasy, a generic tradition that began in the West and unfortunately remains there (with some exceptions). For all people in the West, the medieval period is the only medieval reference we can call “ours.” This despite the fact that many people in the West have links to other cultures (often intimate links). While these exceptions certainly value non-Western cultures, they are up against a wall which tells them “our history [the West’s] is most important, and so you should write analogues of it.”
We are starting to see a serious push against this history. The “other” is creeping its way into the dominant discourse of the West, supplanting its authority to remind us that culture is mostly relative. It’s a slow, drawn out process, just as imperialism and its cultural parasitism took decades to build and decades to tear down. That’s the way it goes, though. When you build an immense hegemonic system of oppression, control, and assimilation, you can’t expect tomorrow to be full of sun when we’ve only just started pulling its ropes on the horizon. At least we have an explanation for the obsession, though. And having that knowledge might be useful some day.
What do you all think? Which recent fantasy novels have you read that don’t include Western settings? I immediately think of work by N. K. Jemisin, Nalo Hopkinson, and Karen Lord. Things I haven’t read included Saladin Ahmed’s Throne of the Crescent Moon, the numerous Philippine SF/F anthologies that Charles A. Tan reminds us about, and a number of interesting works mentioned on the World SF blog (are Lavie Tidhar’s fantasy novels set elsewhere?). Let me know of some others. We could make a wicked list of fantasy set somewhere other than the West!
(Question provied by Mike Reeves-McMillan on Google+)
Share this:
Like this:
Related
Shaun Duke
Follow Me
Newsletter
Support Me
Recent Posts
A Reading List of Dystopian Fiction and Relevant Texts (Apropos of Nothing in Particular)
Why would someone make a list of important and interesting works of dystopian fiction? Or a suggested reading list of works that are relevant to those dystopian works? There is absolutely no reason other than raw interest. There’s nothing going on to compel this. There is nothing in particular one making such a list would hope you’d learn. The lists below are not an exhaustive list. There are bound to be texts I have forgotten or texts you think folks should read that are not listed. Feel free to make your own list and tell me about it OR leave a comment. I’ll add things I’ve missed! Anywhoodles. Here goes:
Share this:
Like this:
Duke’s Best EDM Tracks of 2024
And so it came to pass that I finished up my annual Best of EDM [Insert Year Here] lists. I used to do these on Spotify before switching to Tidal, and I continued doing them on Tidal because I listen to an absurd amount of EDM and like keeping track of the tunes I love the most. Below, you will find a Tidal playlist that should be public. You can listen to the first 50 tracks right here, but the full playlist is available on Tidal proper (which has a free version just like Spotify does). For whatever reason, the embedded playlist breaks the page, and so I’ve opted to link to it here and at the bottom of this post. Embeds are weird. Or you can pull songs into your preferred listening app. It’s up to you. Some caveats before we begin:
Share this:
Like this:
2025: The Year of Something
We’re nine days into 2025, and it’s already full of exhausting levels of controversy before we’ve even had a turnover in power in my home country of the United States. We’ve seen resignations of world leaders, wars continuing and getting worse and worse (you know where), the owner of Twitter continuing his tirade of lunacy and demonstrating why the billionaire class is not to be revered, California ablaze with a horrendous and large wildfire, right wing thinktanks developing plans to out and attack Wikipedia editors as any fascist-friendly organization would do, Meta rolling out and rolling back GenAI profiles on its platforms, and, just yesterday, the same Meta announcing sweeping changes to its moderation policies that, in a charitable reading, encourage hate-based harassment and abuse of vulnerable populations, promotion and support for disinformation, and other problems, all of which are so profound that people are talking about a mass exodus from the platform to…somewhere. It’s that last thing that brings me back to the blog today. Since the takeover at Twitter, social networks have been in a state of chaos. Platforms have risen and fallen — or only risen so much — and nothing I would call stability has formed. Years ago, I (and many others far more popular than me) remarked that we’ve ceded the territory of self-owned or small-scale third party spaces for massive third party platforms where we have minimal to no control or say and which can be stripped away in a tech-scale heartbeat. By putting all our ducks into a bin of unstable chaos, we’re also expending our time and energy on something that won’t last, requiring us to expend more time and energy finding alternatives, rebuilding communities, and then repeating the process again. In the present environment, that’s impossible to ignore.1 This is all rather reductive, but this post is not the place to talk about all the ways that social networks have impacted control over our own spaces and narratives. Another time, perhaps. I similarly don’t have space to talk about the fact that some of the platforms we currently have, however functional they may be, have placed many of us in a moral quagmire, as in the case of Meta’s recent moderation changes. Another time… ↩
Share this:
Like this:
Categories