June 2009

World in the Satin Bag

Reader Question: Should Writers Have English Degrees?

(For some reason I did not write down the name of the person who asked this question, nor did I write down where it came from. So, if you asked this, please leave me a comment here letting me know so I can give you credit!) I think at one point people thought that they had to have a creative writing degree or something related in order to be a good writer. Perhaps a lot of people still think this. The reality is that there’s no reason that you have to get a degree to be a writer or to even be a successful one. While creative writing programs can be wonderful, they can also be terrible depending on what you write. Most of what you learn about writing comes not from taking a class, but from reading and doing. You can take every college course imaginable and there still will be no guarantee of you learning how to be a better writer, or that you will get published as a result. This isn’t to say that creative writing programs, or English programs, aren’t beneficial. You certainly can and probably will learn things from a creative writing class and professors of creative writing can help you develop your craft based on their experiences–the hope is, of course, that these professors have a significant publishing career behind them to add credibility to their advice. But the brutal truth is that having a B.A. in creative writing means diddly squat to most editors, and having one doesn’t automatically mean that you’re better than all those also trying to get published who don’t have such a degree. Creative writing programs tend to be a mixed bag. Some are fantastic, some not so much, but none of them can promise to churn out excellent writers–Iowa Writer’s Workshop does have an excellent track record, though, and that might be worth acknowledging if you’re interested in a degree. And then there is the fact that quite a lot of writers who are successful have no degrees whatsoever. Some have degrees not even related to the writing field at all–look at all the scientists who become science fiction writers, etc. Ultimately, it really doesn’t matter if you have a degree or not: you can be a writer either way. If you want a degree, however, get it because you want to have a career that isn’t necessarily based on something so obviously without guarantee. Creative writing degrees are good, but I’ve always seen them as being largely pointless unless you pursue them at the M.A. or PhD. levels. A B.A. in creative writing is essentially even more useless than a B.A. in literature or English–and let’s face it, a B.A. in almost anything is worth less than the cost of printing the certificate; this is the sad state of affairs in the education world. I’d recommend that those who want to eventually have writing careers should have a fallback plan. There is literally no guarantee that you will ever have a writing career, no matter how much work you put into it, no matter how you do it, whether it be traditionally publishing novels or short stories, or doing it on your own. Being conscious of that when pursuing advanced education will help you make an educated decision about your future. What are you willing to do for a career while you try to develop your fiction skills and get the publishing credits you need to reach that point where you can quit your day job? Thinking about that can certainly help ground your career goals. But let’s not leave it up to me. What do all my readers think about this? Leave a comment. ——————– If you have a question about science fiction, fantasy, writing, or anything related you’d like answered here, whether silly or serious, feel free to send it via email to arconna[at]yahoo[dot]com, tweet it via Twitter to @shaunduke, or leave it in the comments here. Questions are always welcome! If you liked this post, consider stumbling, digging, or linking to it!

World in the Satin Bag

SF/F Links: June June June

Here are some leftovers from last month to keep June interesting, or informative, or something useful like that. Cinematropolis lists ten 2009 science fiction films with promise. A lot of interesting flicks coming out and hopefully this will be a banner year. Apparently people can’t make up their minds. Not too long ago they said that warp was impossible. Now they’re saying it’s not impossible, just really difficult, as if we didn’t already know that. I’m sure everyone has been thinking about how easy it is to make a functioning warp drive and wondering why it is that we don’t have them. I mean, come on! It must be a conspiracy, right? Oil companies. Blame them for no warp. Scalzi highlights a rather interesting idea about how we interacted with some of our non-human Neanderthal relatives: we ate them. And it’s not cannibalism, according to Scalzi. Here’s a lengthy list of science fiction and fantasy writers of African descent, in case you’re interested. Some new names in there! Discover Magazine reminds us of some rules for time travelers. Good stuff! The Incurable Disease of Writing recently posted their May edition of the Just Write Blog Carnival, which links to one of my articles and has a whole lot of other stuff you all might want to check out. And then there’s the late April Creative Writing Goodies Blog Carnival with a whole lot of other links that might be worth checking out. This blog looks interesting. It’s called Toxotai: The Galaxy Project and seems to be one individual’s attempt to build an entire galaxy. Sounds cool to me! Jeremiah Tolbert lists five rejection horror stories (meaning instances in which writers now rather famous were horribly rejected in their early careers). This should give those of us still struggling to get published some hope, or at least further our delusions. Apparently that’s a documentary coming out called Invisible Universe, which will discuss a history of blackness in speculative fiction. I’m really looking forward to it, actually, because it sounds fantastically informative. Jim Van Pelt has a list of ten science fiction books he recommends. Some excellent stuff in there. (Thanks to SF Signal) And, finally, Listverse lists fifteen influential early works of apocalyptic fiction. Some titles I’ve never seen in there and now want to read! And there you have it!

World in the Satin Bag

Interview w/ Matthew Wayne Selznick

No need for introductions; the interview speaks for itself. Enjoy! Thank you for doing this interview with me. First, tell us a bit about yourself. What got you into writing and podcasting, etc.? A brief bio if you will. Thanks for having me! What got me into writing and podcasting are two different things, but I suppose they have common roots. For as long as I can remember, I have needed to tell stories. The telling can take different forms, from being a child and making up complicated, multi-day adventures acted out between dozens of toy soldiers, dinosaurs and other action figures to writing and performing songs and, of course, writingfiction. I wrote because I read. The earliest things I remember reading are Ray Bradbury’s short stories and Edgar Rice Burroughs’ Tarzan novels…and comics. Which is kinda of interesting, because Bradbury’s early influences are Edgar Rice Burroughs and newspaper comic strip serials. Might be why I’ve called Bradbury my “story father.” As far as podcasting goes… I’ve been a DIY (do it yourself) kind of guy since the mid-eighties, when I was in my late teens and early twenties, playing in punk bands. The basic premise of the DIY ethic is this: if you want to make something, make it. If you want to show it to people, put it out there. Don’t wait for someone else to offer you a venue, or a deal — do it yourself. When I first heard about podcasting in October of 2004, it sounded to me like pure DIY: record a “radio” show, throw it on the Internet where you can say anything and do anything and anyone anywhere can hear it. I was sold. I released my first podcast on October 15, 2004… about a week or so after I discovered the medium. Your first published novel is Brave Men Run, a novel about a world in which people with extraordinary powers reveal themselves and demand sovereignty, thus changing the social fabric. What exactly made you want to write this kind of novel? Why a superhero novel that isn’t really about superheroes or clashes between good and evil, but about people–ordinary and otherwise–dealing with a dramatic shift in how the world operates? Largely because, as much as I love comics in general and super-hero comics specifically, I know they’re not a real representation of how the world would really be if people with superpowers existed. Sure, some authors, like Alan Moore in “Watchmen,” for example, have examined the superhero genre in a more realistic setting, but even “Watchmen” is a piece of metafiction — it’s about the genre as much as it is _in_ the genre. I just don’t believe that if a person discovered they could fly, or bend steel in their bare hands, or whatever… I don’t think their first inclination would be to dress up in a costume, put on a mask and fight (or cause) crime. It would take a very unique (read: crazy) personality type, and even in a world where superpowers are common, I just don’t see a superhero / supervillain culture developing. As far as clashes between good and evil… again, the world just isn’t like that. People are driven by their motivations, their needs and desires. That rarely results in anything so black and white as “good” or “evil.” Everyone is a little of both, and just how much of either is in the eye of the beholder. Finally, I like telling stories about people. Folks call “Brave Men Run — A Novel of the Sovereign Era” a “superhero book” because that’s the easiest way to categorize it, but to me, the Sovereign Era stories are about people, fundamentally just like you and me, trying to make the most of the world they’ve been given… just like you and me. Would you say that it might be more possible to have cape-wearing superheroes in a world like ours where superhero culture is so widespread and popular? Or do you see people who found out they had super abilities keeping such things secret? I think some folks might do it — in fact, some people without super powers actually do dress up and fight crime: http://www.worldsuperheroregistry.com/ These people are pretty clearly influenced by comics and comic-book culture, and that gives them a little “out” in terms of their own, um, sanity. If there were people with actual super-powers in our world, would they be influenced by comics or would the comics have been influenced by them? Chicken / egg, I guess. In the Sovereign Era, super-hero comics never had a chance to really be part of western culture, so that archetype doesn’t exist. Brave Men Run is set in the 1980s. What about this era made you want to set a story in it? (Are you secretly into hair bands?) “Brave Men Run — A Novel of the Sovereign Era” is set in 1985 for two reasons: Number one, that was the most volatile era of recent human history. The Cold War was at its hottest since the Cuban Missile Crisis. The United States and the Soviet Union fought wars by proxy in the Middle East, Central and South America and elsewhere. If I’m going to introduce the presence of individuals with remarkable, often dangerous abilities, dramatically there’s no better time — it’s one moreburning cigarette to drop in the dry brush of the world stage, a great set-up for global stress and conflict. Number two, “Brave Men Run — A Novel of the Sovereign Era” is a coming of age story. I was a teenager, albeit a little older than the main character, Nate Charters, in 1985. I’m pretty sure my experience as a teenager is different from the experiences of being a teenager today… so, I wrote what I knew. Setting the book — and the beginning of the Sovereign Era — in the middle of the eighties also lets me have fun with cultural references and allows me to use the

World in the Satin Bag

RIP: David Eddings

I unfortunately have some sad news for those of you who haven’t heard.  Author David Eddings, who wrote some of the best fantasy books since Tolkien pioneered the genre, has passed away at the age of 77.  He wrote such memorable series as The Belgariad and The Malloreon, along with a dozen other novels.  He will be sorely missed.

World in the Satin Bag

SF/F Links: June Batch

Because what could be better than interesting links to other places? A lot of things, I’m sure, but that’s not the point. For now, enjoy these: Juno Books has an incredibly informative list of recent book sales figures that you all might be fascinated by. Really detailed stuff and rather telling of how the book industry is doing. The list makes some interesting points on the age of readers, which might be worth noting. Who Is Caleb G? discusses the marginalization of science fiction. Some basic, but exceptionally valid points are made. The genre really is as important as those of us who read it say. A bit of random trivia: ten fun facts about Kenya. Yup. Random, I know, but you might learn something useful. Bloggasm talks about basically one of the most useless studies on the effects of giving away electronic copies of books on book sales themselves. Basically the fellow wasted his time studying only to tell us that “oh, well, yeah, we see sales, but we don’t know if that’s because of other factors beyond giving them away as electronic copies.” So, essentially pointless. Any moron could have done this and come up with the same thing. *rant over* Mashable has 100+ of the best authors on Twitter, conveniently divided into genres. AME has a useful marketing roadmap form you can use to, well, develop a marketing roadmap. Pretty self-explanatory and particularly useful for future novelists who want to be published. As cool as it may sound that scientists are creating zombie fireants by introducing a species of fly that lays eggs in the ants, which grow and kill them, I can’t help thinking that this is going to bite us in the butt later. Anyone else think fiddling with introducing non-native zombie-fying species is a bad idea? The Book Publicity Blog has a whole series on sending and receiving review copies of books. Check the bottom of this post for the various other sections. Definitely worth reading. Follow the Reader has some great statistical information about book buyers that might be of interest. I’m particularly astonished at how the elderly are taking the whole eBook thing. Oh, and to all of you idiots who think reading is dying: you’re wrong and the stats on this page say so. Eat it. Best Fantasy Books asks if speculative fiction is at its zenith. I’m not so sure. I think the problem is that what tends to get attention is what sells, and that’s never necessarily been what is of high quality in the writing world. There’s good stuff out there, you just can’t always rely on the bestseller’s lists to find them. The Scattering makes an interesting argument about Neanderthals being like the Androids of Blade Runner (or other films, etc.). I don’t think it’s entirely accurate, but it still makes one think about what our role may have been in their extinction. The Litter Box has a hilarious list of five worthless droids. Cracked me up. Johnny Five! Flights of Fantasy lists five uses for dinosaurs in fantasy. I prefer using them as mounts–a Velociraptor specifically (names Bill). And that’s it for this time around. A lot of links that hopefully will not bore. Anywho!

Scroll to Top